"Who cares" is exactly right. Pikes were just rated the number 1 fraternity in America. Even the worst chapter (which Ole Miss isn't) is as good as any fraternity on any campus. You can always tell top houses because people spend their time on websites bashing them. I've noticed this happens on several of the sororities as well. They're always trying to knock you off the top. Other than Sigma Chi the fraternities at Ole Miss "suck" nationally.
Who cares what a bunch of hillbilly rednecks from Mississippi think of Pike? They were just named the number 1 fraternity in America, surpassing Sigma Chi. No one cares what you outhouse using rednecks think.